Brick Wall
We all have brick walls in Genealogy research and the following is mine:

James Moro Robinson.
1815 - 1883
My great great grandfather
by Richard Wilt

      James was born in Virginia possibly in Goochland or Rockbridge County, VA. The first record I can find for him is his marriage to Polly Ann Chittum born in Rockbridge County, Va. The first document is a Virginia Marriage Bond signed by Polly's mother Malinda Chittum and her uncle. Polly's father died in 1824. The signature for James was only his mother Catherine Robinson. James and Polly were married February 12, 1835 in Rockbridge County, VA.

      James and Polly owned a small farm and James worked as a cobbler and records found in my grandmother's papers indicate he was quite good at his trade. James and Polly had 15 children of which my great grandfather was number twelve. James and Polly lived what appears to be a normal uneventful life until early April 1854 James and his brother-in-law, Hezekiah H. Chittum got into an argument over a boundary on their abutting properties. The argument grew into a full out battle and they started shooting at each other. Unluckily Hezekiah was wounded and James was arrested and charged with "Felonious shooting of his brother-in-law over a property line dispute" on April 13, 1854 by the grand jury stated as follows: The Grand jury appeared in court according to their adjournment and having retired, after some time returned in court and presented An Indictment against James Robinson for shooting with intent to kill “A true Bill”

      On September 12, 1854 At a circuit court began and held for Rockbridge county at the courthouse on Tuesday the twelfth day of September eighteen hundred and fifty four and in the 79th year of the commonwealth

      Present the Honorable Lucas Thomspon Judge of the eleventh Industrial circuit in Virginia  

      James M. Robinson who stands indicted of felonious shooting appeared in court in discharge of his recognizance and on the motion of the attorney for the commonwealth and for reasons appearing to the court the trial of the said James M. Robinson is continued until the next tomorrow whereupon the said James M. Robinson with William Leach, Isaac Potter and Samuel D. Nelson his securities here in court acknowledge themselves to be indebted to the commonwealth of Virginia the said James M. Robinson in the sum of one hundred dollars and the said William Leach, Isaac Potter and Samuel d. Nelson jointly and security in the sum of one hundred dollars to be levied of their respective good and chattels lands and tenements and to the said commonwealth rendered – Yet upon the condition that if the said James M. Robinson shall make his personal appearance before the Judge of the court at the courthouse on the first day of April term next to answer an Indictment against him for the felonious shooting and shall not depart thence without the leave of the court then this recognizance shall be void.

      Hezekiah Chittum, Lucinda C. Chittum, William Henry Fisher, John Alex Fisher and Hugh J. Wilson came into the court and severally acknowledged themselves to be indebted to the commonwealth of Virginia in the sum of one hundred dollars each of them repective goods and chattels lands and tenements and to the said commonwealth rendered. Yet upon this condition that of the land Hezekial Chittum, Lucinda C. Chittum, William H. Fisher, John A. Fisher and Hugh J. Wilson do and each of them shall make their personal appearance before the Judge of this court on the first day of April term next at the courthouse, then and there to give evidence on behalf of the commonwealth against James

      James M. Robinson who stands indicted of felonious shooting and shall not depart thence without the leave of the court them this recognizance to be void otherwise to remain in full force.

      On April 4, 1855 At a circuit court continued by adjournment and held for Rockbridge county at the courthouse on Saturday the 14th day of April A.D. Eighteen hundred and fifty five and the 79th year of the commonwealth.  

      (The Honorable Lucas Thomspon Judge of the eleventh Industrial circuit in Virginia)  

      Present the same Judge as on yesterday.

James Robinson alias James M. Robinson who stands indicted of felonious shooting again appeared in discharge of his cognizance and was set to the bar in custody of this jailor of the county and the jury sworn for his trail were brought into court by the sheriff of this county and upon their oath do say that the said James M. Robinson is not guilty as in the pleading he hath alleged. Therefore it is considered by the court that the said James alias James M. Robinson be acquitted and discharged of said offense and thereof without delay.

        This case caused James Moro Robinson to sell all his property and possessions to pay the lawyers representing him in this case. Also two sons indentured themselves to neighboring farms to help pay their father’s debt to the lawyers. It seems the law has not changed in all these years, an individual will go bankrupt just to defend themselves and to pay lawyers.

      During the course of this trial James was represented by no less than three lawyers. To pay the lawyers he sold his farm, all of his personal property, even supplies such as corn, wheat, cattle, sheep, hogs and chickens. He also sold all of this equipment used in the making and repairing of shoes which left him very little to support his family. Two of his sons, John C, and James indentured themselves to neighboring farms and pledged all of their earnings for one year to pay their father's debt to the lawyers. After his acquittal there is very little found in any records for James. Of course, he owned no property so he does not appear on any tax schedules at the time.

      The next record I could find for James and Polly was the 1860 census in Rockbridge County, VA with 9 of their children still living at home.

      In the Census of 1870 taken on July 16, 1870 James, Polly and children are still living in Rockbridge County, VA but in the Census of 1870 taken in Upshur County on August 16, 1870 James, Polly and 6 of their children are listed. In the 1880 census taken in Upshur County, WV James and Polly are living next door to two of their older sons, John and James with their families.

      From documents passed down by my grandmother, James worked as a cobbler up to his death on June 8, 1883. Polly had died between the time of the 1880 census and the death of James because James is listed on his death certificate in Upshur County, WV as being a widower as documented by his son Thomas R. Robinson.

      Due to the experience I have had in 2013 and 2014 I can understand what lawyers can do to you in fees. My fees were probably much less than my great great grandfather had to pay since he was fighting for his life.

      I can not find the graves of James or Polly. Due to expense I doubt very much if their graves are marked and to date I have been ubable to find either of them listed on any cemetery lists in Upshur County. Since they lived in the area near Audra either or both could be buried in Barbour or Upshur Counties. Polly may have died of Diphtheria since she was living very near her son Charles Wesley Robinson and Charles', wife Harriett died of Diphtheria on December 28, 1880. On January 30, 1881 Thomas had a son age 2 die of unknown causes, and another son died on February 2, 1881 age 9 months die of unknown causes believed to have been Diphtheria. The one son was listed living in Barbour County and the other was listed as living in Usphur County. I believe that they lived very close to the county line which is one of the reasons I am having trouble finding the exact location of where they lived. There was a large number of deaths during the winter of 1880/81 diagnosed as Diphtheria and Pneumonia.

      Maybe with more work and research I will find James's ancestry and with luck may find his grave.



      Picture of J.M. Robinson and Polly Ann Chittum Robinson was gotten from the Teets Web site managed by John Teets.

      James brought his family to WV from VA between July 16, 1870 and August 16, 1870 because he is found in the VA (Rockbridge Co.) census on July 16, 1870 and in the WV (Upshur County) census on August 16, 1870 WV (Upshur Co) census on August 16, 1870.

Deed of Trust Rockbridge County, VA

      This deed made the eleventh day of Apr 1854 (April 11, 1854) between James M. Robinson of the one part and Isaac Potter of the other part; that the said James M. Robinson doth grant unto the said Isaac Potter the following property viz twenty one acres & half of land lying on the waters of Buffalo Creek adjoining the land of Hezekiah Chittum, Hugh J. & Thos Wilson, Granville Campbell & Wm Drain, & being a part of a tract of land purchased of Wm B. Wilson by Sd Robinson & Chittum , one dark brown horse & 1 red cow, Eight head of hogs, 1 clock, two bed steads & bedding, 1 cupboard, 1 set drawers, two pots, two awes, 1 Shovel heaugh, a full set of shoe makers tools & lastz, one hand saw, one auger, one set gear for plough, a lot of old irons & farming utensils, five chains, 1 square table & two falling leaf tables & table furniture, 1 vinegar Bbl.

      The serving of seven bushel of wheat on the land specified above. The wages of John Robinson, son of sd James M. Robinson which will be done from Robert Montgomery on the twenty fifth day of December 1854 to the amount of seventy Dollars being a balance after ten being paid out Jno’s hire, also the hire of Monroe Robinson son of sd James M. Robinson due on the 5th of Dec 1854 from Jno Montgomery for the sum of fifty Dollars in trust to secure the payment of a note due to S.D. Nelson & Co. on the 29th Dec 1853 for the amount of thirty nine Dollars & fifty three cents also a not due S.D. & W. P Nelson on the 29th Dec 1854 for the amount fo three Dollars & sixty cents, also an amount due Wm. P. Nelson & Co. April 10th 1854 for about the amount of one hundred & twenty five Dollars a note due Wm Rogers Apr 11th 1854 for the amount of eight Dollars 96 cents due Setcher & Curry on discharge of Sd Jas M. Robinson from the the charge of shooting H. Chittum. Fifteen Dollars also due Rob L. Doyle fifteen Dollars in the same way & time. The sd James M. Robinson covenants & agrees that he will warrant gererally the property hereby conveyed to the Sd Isaac Potter trustee the deed of trust will be due on the first day of January Eighteen hundred & fifty five and if the debts specified above and not paid by James M. Robinson on or before 1st January 1855, it will be in the power of any one of the above named persons to require sd trustee to put the sd property to sale after due notice having been given, witnessed the following signature and seals the year & day above written;
Signed: James M. Robinson
Isaac Potter

Trial and Acquittal of James Moro Robinson of Rockbridge, Virginia

Charge : Felonious shooting of his brother-in-law, Hezekiah H. Chittum over a property line dispute. (Thursday 13th April 1854)

&nsbp; &nsbp;   At a circuit continued by adjournment and hold for Rockbridge County at the courthouse on Thursday the thirteenth day of April AD eighteen hundred and fifty for and in the 78th year of the commonwealth Present the same Judge as yesterday.

The Grand jury appeared in court according to their adjournment and having retired, after some time returned in court and presented An Indictment against James Robinson for shooting with intent to kill “A true Bill”

      Also an indictment against Anderson West for selling liquor “A true Bill” and also an indictment against Robert Six for a trespass and assault and robbery: A true Bill” and then the grand jury having nothing further at present and the attorney for the commonwealth no other matters today before them they were discharged.
(Tuesday 12th September 1854 )

      At a circuit court began and held for Rockbridge county at the courthouse on Tuesday the twelfth day of September eighteen hundred and fifty four and in the 79th year of the commonwealth Present the Honorable Lucas Thomspon Judge of the eleventh Industrial circuit in Virginia

      James M. Robinson who stands indicted of felonious shooting appeared in court in discharge of his recognizance and on the motion of the attorney for the commonwealth and for reasons appearing to the court the trial of the said James M. Robinson is continued until the next tomorrow whereupon the said James M. Robinson with William Leach, Isaac Potter and Samuel D. Nelson his securities here in court acknowledge themselves to be indebted to the commonwealth of Virginia the said James M. Robinson in the sum of one hundred dollars and the said William Leach, Isaac Potter and Samuel d. Nelson jointly and security in the sum of one hundred dollars to be levied of their respective good and chattels lands and tenements and to the said commonwealth rendered – Yet upon the condition that if the said James M. Robinson shall make his personal appearance before the Judge of the court at the courthouse on the first day of April term next to answer an Indictment against him for the felonious shooting and shall not depart thence without the leave of the court then this recognizance shall be void.

(Wednesday 13th September, 1854)

Wednesday 13th, day of September eighteen hundred and fifty four.

      James M. Robinson who stands indited of felonious shooting appeared in court in discharge of his recognition and on the motion of the attorney for the commonwealth and for reasons appearing to the court the trial of the said James M. Robinson in continued until the next tome whereupon the said James M. Robinson with William Leach, Isaac Potter and Samuel D. Nelson has securities here in court acknowledged themselves to be indebted to the commonwealth of Virginia the said James M. Robinson

      “You shall well and truly to the best of your ability keep this jury and witnesses speak to them yourself nor surfer any other person to speak to them, touching any matter relative to this trial until they return into court tomorrow.

      And therefor the said James Robinson alias James M. Robinson with James J. Davidson and William Leach his securities here in court acknowledge themselves to be shall be indebted unto the commonwealth of Virginia the said Robinson in the sum of one hundred dollars and the said Davidson and Leach in the sum of fifty dollars each of their respective goods and chattel lands and tenements to be levied and to the commonwealth rendered-- Yet upon this condition that if the said Robinson shall make his personal appearance before the Judge of this court at the courthouse on tomorrow morning at ten o’clock to answer an indictment against him for felonious shooting and shall not depart thence without the leave of this court then this recognizance shall be void.

      Hezekiah Chittum, Lucinda C. Chittum, William Henry Fisher, John Alex Fisher and Hugh J. Wilson came into the court and severally acknowledged themselves to be indebted to the commonwealth of Virginia in the sum of one hundred dollars each of them repective goods and chattels lands and tenements and to the said commonwealth rendered. Yet upon this condition that of the land Hezekial Chittum, Lucinda C. Chittum, William H. Fisher, John A. Fisher and Hugh J. Wilson do and each of them shall make their personal appearance befor the Judge of this court on the first day of April term next at the courthouse, then and there to give evidence on behalf of the commonwealth against James

      M. Robinson who stands indicted of felonious shooting and shall not depart thence without the leave of the court them this recognizance to be void otherwise to remain in full force.
(Saturday 14th , 1855)

      At a circuit court continued by adjournment and held for Rockbridge county at the courthouse on Saturday the 14th day of April A.D. Eighteen hundred and fifty five and the 79th year of the commonwealth.
(The Honorable Lucas Thomspon Judge of the eleventh Industrial circuit in Virginia)
Present the same Judge as on yesterday.

      James Robinson alias James M. Robinson who stands indicted of felonious shooting again appeared in discharge of his cognizance and was set to the bar in custody of this jailor of the county and the jury sworn for his trail were brought into court by the sheriff of this county and upon their oath do say that the said James M. Robinson is not guilty as in the pleading he hath alleged. Therefor it is considered by the court that the said James alias James M. Robinson be acquitted and discharged of said offense and thereof without delay.

      This case caused James Moro Robinson to sell all his property and possessions to pay the lawyers representing him in this case. Also two sons indentured themselves to neighboring farms to help pay their father’s debt to the lawyers. It seems the law has not changed in all these years, an individual will go bankrupt just defend themselves and to pay lawyers.

      After losing everything in his defense James moved his family to the western part of Virginia and settled in Barbour County. Financially James never recovered from this case, even though he was never held responsible for the shooting in his family.
Name:Polly Robinson
Event Type:Census
Event Date:1850
Event Place:Rockbridge county, part of, Rockbridge, Virginia, United States
Gender:Female
Age:30
Marital Status:
Race (Original): Race: Birthplace:Virginia
Birth Year (Estimated):1820
House Number:177 Family Number:182Line Number:39
Affiliate Publication Number:M432Affiliate Film Number:973GS
Film number:444963 Digital
Folder Number:004206463Image Number:00270 Household

Name Gender Age Birthplace
James Robinson M 35 Virginia
Polly Robinson F30 Virginia
John RobinsonM14Virginia
Susan RobinsonF12Virginia
James M RobinsonM10Virginia
Malinda RobinsonF9Virginia
William RobinsonM7Virginia
Andrew RobinsonM5Virginia
Alfred RobinsonM3Virginia
Hezekiah RobinsonM1Virginia
Malinda ChillumF62Virginia

Census Rockbridge Co. VA 1850
Robinson,
James M age 35 b. VA
Polly F age 30 b. VA
John M age 14 b. VA
Susan F age 12 b. VA
James M. M age 10 b. VA
Malinda F age 9 b. VA
William M age 7 b. VA
Andrew M age 5 b. VA
Alfred M age 3 b. VA
Hezekiah M age 1 b VA
Malinda Chittum F age 62 b. VA

Census Rockbridge Co. VA 1860
Robinson,
Jas M. age 46 M Shoe Maker
Polly A. age 44 F
Jason A. age 22 M
Malinda age 18 F
Wm age 16 M
Andrew age 14 M
Alford age 12 M
Hezekiah age 10 M
Mary P. age 9 F
Thos F age 7 M
Chas W age 2 M

Census 1880 July 16th Union District Upshur County, WV dwelling 172 family 173
Robinson,
James M. W M age 63 Farmer
Polly A. W F age 62 Wife Keeping house

I believe Polly died between July 1880 and June 1883 since James was listed as being a widower on his death certificate
 


Main Page
Biographies